Scientists have studied different types of anxiety treatments and found calming collars for dogs to be extremely effective at reducing fear and anxiety. There are different types of calming dog collars: some use pheromones, and others use natural essentials oils and aromatherapy.
How Do Calming Collars for Dogs Actually Work?
A dog calming collar is designed to soothe anxiety and fear regardless of the source. How effective the collar will be in different situations depends entirely on the animal.
There are two types of calming collars for dogs. Aromatherapydog collars are natural and do not use any chemicals to calm dogs; they are also less popular and haven't been studied well, but many pet owners are finding that a few have been very effective. Our first pick below is a natural calming collar for dogs with an herb composition.
A pheromone collar for dogs (or DAP collar, Dog Appeasing Pheromone collar) is the most popular choice. Most veterinarians use and recommend them, and unlike natural collars, they've been scientifically proven to work (Landsberg, 2015; Gaultier, 2008).
Research of pheromones and how they affect animals have been previously conducted (Liberles, 2014). We know today that pheromones, which are natural chemical substances produced by the dogs themselves, affect their physiology and behavior.
Dog pheromone collars simply mimic the pheromone release that a mother dog naturally produces to calm down her puppies. All canines will recognize this throughout their lives because that's how all mammals are wired.
Below are some of the best calming collars for dogs that we've tried, reviewed and ranked in the order of effectiveness, ingredients used and their price tag:
The Effectiveness of a Dog Calming Collar
We currently don't have any conclusive evidence on the effectiveness of aromatherapy-based calming collars for dogs, but anecdotal evidence is there and many pet owners and veterinarians report great results with some of them.
A dog pheromone collar has a stronger backing to it. Based on canine pheromone studies and DAP collar studies, a pheromone collar for dogs was developed to mimic the animal's natural release of hormones. Today, there's a large number of research on how effective Dog Appeasing Pheromones are for helping canines deal with anxiety and fear.
For example, these calming dog collars have been proven to:
These are just some of the examples of scientific literature behind the effectiveness of pheromone collar for dogs, with many more studies available. It's quite clear that using Dog Appeasing Pheromones is an effective way to help deal with anxiety in pets, regardless of what the cause of anxiety really is.
Why the Bad Dog Calming Collar Reviews?
If you talk to some pet owners, or take a look at pheromone dog collar reviews from the below mentioned products (e.g. an average Amazon review rating is 3/5), you'll notice a pattern. So how can that be if there's a large number of research showing the effectiveness of these collars?
The reason is because the effectiveness of Dog Appeasing Pheromones, and thereby any type of calming collar for dogs, will depend entirely on the animal. Some dogs react well to them and will be highly affected, while others will experience only mild effects or none at all. There's no way to know other than to try and observe the effects for at least 1 month. You may also need to try several different options until you find what works.
The bottom line on the evidence of anxiety treatments for dogs is that Dog Appeasing Pheromones are one of the very few treatments currently proven to work, and the best calming collar for dogs may be the cheapest option for pet owners. There are other ways such as anxiety vests (which have been studied but the evidence is still not there) as well as more intrusive options like anxiety medication (which can have more side effects).
How to Choose the Best Dog Calming Collar for Your Pet
When trying to pick the best calming collar for dogs, decide between the all-natural approach (aromatherapy and natural oils based dog calming collar) or pheromone collar for dogs. The below list contains the most effective best calming collars for dogs including herbal ones and pheromone based collars.
For aromatherapy dog calming collar, pay attention to how long the collar will last (3 months longevity is top of the line) and what type of herbs have been used to make up the collar. The product's page will have all those details.
For dog pheromone collar, you want to take a look at the longevity as well, but most importantly, pay attention the DAP composition in the ingredients list. This number shows how much Dog Appeasing Pheromone is used, thereby how effective it will be. The higher the number, the stronger the pheromone mimic release.
Majority of pheromone dog collars use low concentration levels (average 0.02%) and they aren't that effective. Today, most veterinarians will recommend Adaptil dog calming collar (or anything close), because they have the highest DAP composition of 4-6%. Most of the best calming dog collars with DAP last no longer than 4 weeks.
Remember that you need to find a proper fit once you choose a good calming collar for a dog. Picking the right size and making sure it fits properly is vital to how effective a pet calming collar will be on your pooch.
How to Use a Dog Calming Collar
Once you've picked the best dog calming collar for your dog, and you found the right fit, the actual use of it is very simple and straightforward.
Directions for use:
- Take out the dog calming collar out of its original packaging and remove everything from it (all tabs, etc.)
- Bend the buckle in half between the holes in the buckle.
- Wrap the calming collar around your dog's neck and then feed it through the holes.
- The collar must feel a little loose to allow for movement around the dog's neck (again, see the above linked guide on how to fit a dog collar properly).
- That's it. Remember to wash your hands afterwards.
Below are the six picks of top rated calming collars for dogs that we liked the most.
The Best Calming Collar for Dogs Brands
1Calm Me Down Calming Pet Collar
by Herbal Calming Collars
Find it on Amazon | Unavailable on
- What are the advantages of career counselling
- Can you get chlamydia without HIV
- Do debt collectors call you
- Can we survive without the nerves
- What is a reference business
- What do we do on Navratri
- Video classifieds in India
- Why does some meat bleed when cooked
- What are the synecdoche examples in literature
- Who are Tulu
- How is technology helping the insurance industry
- Is feminism pointless
- How can I prevent head sweating
- What are the best chemical engineering blogs
- Where are super computers used in Pakistan
- Where should you put DLL files
- How is China exploiting India